The best and worst portraits according to critics

MacDonald’s portrait of Aboriginal professor and activist Marcia Langton is equally striking, giving it just the right twist to keep it from being purely academic. Langton is shown staring up at a cloudy sky. She looks contrite, perhaps reflecting on the defeat of the “Voice” referendum, for which she was a leading advocate.

In contrast, Ben Howe’s Kelly and Sammy The film barely conceals its reliance on photography. Kylie Moore-Gilbert and Sami Shah pose stiffly for the camera, looking like exhibits from Madame Tussauds. Matt Adnutt Inheriting the rhythmWinner of the Packing Room Award, this work feels more like a Bollywood poster than a portrait. Baker Boy’s face has the kind of expression that asks him to pose for the camera, while the background is painted in incongruous red, blue and black slashes, suggesting that the artist must never abandon figuration for abstraction.

For Nick Stathopoulos, painting David Stratton in grey tones was meant to hint at the veteran film critic’s health and eyesight problems, but the overall effect is not somber as grim and oppressive. Ben Smith’s near-photographic portrait of Darren Dyer suffers a similar failure, with a row of flowers placed at waist height, giving the impression of a filmmaker hiding in the bushes trying not to attract attention. The most striking thing about Tim Owens’s portrait of Matildas forward Cortney Vine is the title: On the benchThe painting itself is beautifully done but lacks inspiration.

One of the most striking works is Zoe Young’s portrait of food writer Jill Dupleix, which is notable for its bright yellow hue and heavily jagged composition, which is almost futuristic. Tactile distortions make the subject’s feet and legs larger than her head and torso, giving the impression that the artist painted the work under a nearby coffee table. Details are a bit fuzzy, but the glare of the sun provides a partial excuse for the painting, which is likely a result of style and haste.

Caroline Zielinski can already proudly boast a series of savage attacks from the London tabloids on her portrait of screen heartthrob Jacob Elordi, which has been described several times as “abstract”. I have my reservations about Zielinski’s pretentious painting style, but when the tabloids call it “abstract”, it fully exposes the media’s level of ignorance and visual illiteracy regarding visual art. This indestructible artist seems to be enjoying her moment of international fame, and she probably is. No one is going to get mad at a fool’s comment.

Of the works that felt too gimmicky to be comfortable, Sean Gladwell’s “Julian Assange” has to be high up, with the subject’s face transformed into a hot air balloon adorned with the Stars and Stripes, peace doves, helicopters, rows of waving figures, and a picture of what I assume is the late Queen Elizabeth. The portrait was said to have been drawn on the banknote using a bar of chocolate, which put the trustees on the spot, inviting them to use the prize money to make a statement in support of Assange, who was recently released from a British prison. After avoiding extradition to the U.S.Although not wanting to miss out on the publicity opportunity, the judges refrained from awarding him further honours.

Other exaggerated novelty photos include Drew Bickford’s “portrait” of artist duo Soda Jerk, which looks like a horror movie poster with almost no clues. Meanwhile, Yoshio Honjo’s Akira Igawa It’s a clever imitation of traditional Japanese painting, but it’s hard to tell the fashion designer against the backdrop of armor and dragons. At least it’s well done, much better than some of the other works. Whitney Duan’s Fluffy (Jordan Gorgos), Reminds me of an old rug that is destined to become a dust magnet. I don’t know what this article (or title) says about Jordan Gogos’ fashion designs.

It’s been a big year for queerness. From Jaq Grantford’s painting of ABC Classics host Ed Le Brocq as a centaur to Natasha Walsh’s nipple-pinching pose from a Fontainebleau School painting, fashion duo Nicol & Ford are very different in scale and style, but both share a look-at-me defiance.

It’s this obvious, eye-catching quality that undermines their potential as potential winners. Compared to Jones’s gloomy, awkward portrait of Tim Winton in a T-shirt, the drama of these paintings hits us like a trumpet call. Jones imbues her subjects with a sense of interiority, while Walsh and Grantford opt for spectacle.

There were four finalists from the Studio A collective, a social enterprise that works with artists with intellectual disabilities. The best was Thom Roberts’s Big Bang Banga colorful portrait of Ken Dorn with four eyes, a rainbow-striped jumper and pink and yellow cat ears shaped like opera house sails. Roberts has surpassed Ken Dorn.

loading

The Winn Landscape Prize has effectively become an award for Aboriginal art, but the two Aboriginal artists who won the portrait prize were far less impressive: Adrian Jangala Robertson’s rough daub paintings were known as Jumping Julie, Yuendumuwhich is at least one of the best works in the show; and a strange work by Robert Fielding that makes the artist Tapi Njinja Goodwin look ghostly and sinister. All the words engraved on the painting do not add to its appeal.

As one Archibald subculture rises, another is pushed aside. A few years ago, the exhibition was full of Chinese immigrants, most of whom had painting skills that put those in other fields to shame. There is no way these artists will stop entering, or start producing inferior work. One hopes they are simply victims of fashion, not politics. In any case, at a time when the Art Gallery of NSW is desperate to cultivate private donors, it sends a discouraging message to the Chinese community, which is famous for its wealth and willingness to spend. Gina Rinehart may be richer, but, as we have seen, she has stricter standards for portraiture.

this Archibald, Wynne and Salman Prize Exhibition The exhibition will be on display at the Art Gallery of New South Wales in Sydney until September 8. It will then tour across New South Wales and the Northern Territory.