[ad_1]
This marginalization narrative has helped many political leaders use military intervention, as it is notorious for, to “bring democracy” and “civilization” to many parts of the world.
Lolwah Al Khater, Minister of State for International Cooperation at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Qatar Already called An American right-wing political commentator made a controversial statement, calling it “reverse colonization,” in which “third world countries” bring chaos and disorder to civilized areas. This is a “flawed statement.”
In a brazen and controversial statement His X platformMatt Walsh argues that “Europe colonized the world by bringing civilization to uncivilized places.”
He went on to describe: “What is happening now is like a reverse colonization. The Third World is bringing chaos and disorder to places that were once civilized.”
“This is colonization with all its benefits lost,” he claimed.
This prompted a flurry of reactions online, including one from Minister Al Hartl, who was quick to criticise Walsh’s claims, saying his argument “assumes that civilisations other than Europe do not exist”, which she said was a “fallacy” and “factually incorrect”.
Al Carter first criticized Walsh’s controversial remarks with a sarcastic tone, saying: “It’s funny because there was a ‘civilized’ gentleman named Matt Walsh who traveled thousands of miles to the ‘uncivilized world’ to find the answer to ‘what is a woman’…at least according to his documentary.”
Alcatel referring to Walsh’s 2022 documentary What is a Woman? , in which he travels around the world to interview different people and asks them if they can tell him what a woman is.
“Sarcasm aside,” she continued, “here’s how to methodologically deconstruct some of the fallacies in Mr. Walsh’s flawed statement.”
“Mr. Walsh wants to define women, so here we also need to define ‘civilized and uncivilized’?” the outspoken Qatari official added.
Al Carter went on to criticize conservative Walsh (who is also the author of a children’s book), saying: “This statement presupposes that other civilizations outside of Europe do not exist, which is a fallacy and is factually incorrect.”
“Mr. Walsh says colonization ‘brought’ civilization, but what about the millions of people who were ‘brought’ as slaves from ‘uncivilized places’ to the ‘civilized world’? Can we at least give them some credit for their contribution to civilizing these places?”
Al Khater pointed out another inconsistency in his review, noting that “it is another fallacy to equate (a) military colonization by force, including (b) mass killing/extermination of entire regions, and (c) illegal plunder of wealth, with ‘legal immigration’.”
“For the sake of this argument, let’s assume that military colonization had ‘civilized’ the colonies (remember we didn’t know what civilization was). How can this justify the mass killing and plundering of others? Couldn’t they have ‘civilized’ these areas without plundering others’ wealth and exterminating them?” she said.
“We can go on,” she concluded, attaching a video clip from Walsh’s documentary.
White superiority, or the “white man’s burden,” stems from the idea that the West must bear the responsibility for bringing civilization to the rest of the world.
Many of these claims are used to support the West’s legacy of military intervention and imperialism.
Western officials, meanwhile, have long pitted the West against the rest of the world.
In October 2022, the EU’s foreign policy chief sparked global outrage by describing Europe as a garden of political freedom and economic prosperity and pointing to the rest of the world as a “jungle” that Europe sought to protect.
Josep Borrell has been urged to apologize for describing the world outside Europe as a potentially uncivilized “jungle.”
“Europe is a garden,” Borrell said in an interview. speech Yet “much of the rest of the world is jungle, and the jungle may be invading the garden,” he told a news conference in Belgium on Thursday.
This marginalization narrative has helped many political leaders use military intervention to, as they infamously claim, “bring democracy” and “civilization” to many parts of the world.
Former US President George W. Bush took advantage of the differences in world civilizations and set the West against other civilizations, especially Islam, as a means of justifying his “global war on terror” policy.
Post-9/11 EraBush then created a new world enemy: terrorism aligned with Islam, or “Islamic terrorism.”
The former US president also did not hesitate to use the terms “terrorists in the desert” and “jungle“In his 2002 State of the Union address, he further deepened the Orientalist perspective that prevails in Western narratives about the Middle East.
[ad_2]
Source link
